The entire film is filled with nothing more than scientific inaccuraci. With matthew pohlkamp, natalie pelletier, erich riegelmann, maggie rose hudson. The new dwayne johnson movie san andreas is a heartpumping thrill ride, a throwback to the peopleinperil disaster flicks that irwin allen made in the 1970s but with stateoftheart special. With the aid of movie magic, the film perpetuates three big scientific inaccuracies. If this movie has raised your interest about real earthquakes and about reasonable ways to prepare for unexpected emergencies in general, there are many places you can go for reliable information. Throughout the movie, larger quakes are followed by smaller ones. The science behind san andreas mnn mother nature network. Actor dwayne johnson has said an expert seismologist signed off on the script for. The san andreas community note includes chapterbychapter summary and analysis, character list, theme list, historical context, author biography and quizzes written by community members like you. Could that really happen a seismologist explores the. Lucy jones lists scientific inaccuracies and factual errors in san andreas depiction of earthquakes. The san andreas has long been considered one of the most dangerous.
In reality, the san andreas is a rightlateral fault, and the westward pacific plate shifts northward relative to the north american plate. The last good disaster movie i saw was the towering inferno, and you know that was a long, long time ago. Mar 01, 2020 seismologist screens the rocks san andreas, outlines all of its gross inaccuracies the film got a surprising amount of things right, but a lot of the science hilariously wrong. San andreas is a landbased fault, which moves along the rupture horizontally by the way, the fault would never open up as it does in the movie, leaving a gaping chasm in the ground. Jun 01, 2015 so the san andreas fault, where it is visible, simply looks like a line on the landscape not the gaping chasm shown in the movie. It offers us a teachable moment, to separate the myths from reality about earthquakes. San andreas fault zone the san andreas fault zone is located in san francisco, california and is more than 800 miles long and at least 10 miles deep. The san andreas system in northern california consists of five major branches with an overall length of about 1,25o miles. Seismologist highlights inaccuracies in upcoming san andreas. San andreas quake 210 movie clip predicting a quake. Now, dwayne johnsons san andreas is out, dramatizing and exaggerating the very real possibility of california suffering a series of severe earthquakes along the san andreas fault. The movieclips channel is the largest collection of licensed movie clips on the web. And there are several inaccuracies in the movie san andreas that require. Much like most horror movies made in the last decade, or the entire transformers series, san andreas is entertaining, but not really in the way the director probably intended.
Here are her thoughts on the movie and the science or lack thereof behind it. San andreas, of course, had much better special effects. On the accuracy of the films premise of an earthquake swarm. Discover whether san andreas could actually happen. Find out if the san andreas movie is accurate as we pit science vs. But it has a bit of a fatalistic scenario of destruction one we hope will never actually happen. Could the earthquake that happened in the san andreas movie happen in real life. Mythbusting the new san andreas movie sorting fact. Could an earthquake along the san andreas fault create a large tsunami. So, in that sense, san andreas is more than just escapist disasterporn. Geological survey, found some factual inaccuracies. Nov 04, 2015 while a swarm could account for the multiple quakes in the movie, the san andreas quakes have magnitudes far higher than those of usual swarm earthquakes.
This is not what would happen if somehow the san andreas fault line became unstable and shift its location. Jun 02, 2015 earthquake blockbuster shakes up the box office, but cnns jeanne moos asks how san andreas measures on the accuracy scale. In the film, opening this friday, a previously unknown fault near the hoover dam in nevada ruptures and jiggles the san andreas. The san andreas fault is a rightlateral strikeslip. People may have heard about san andreas fault because of the movie that was made with dwayne johnson, but know very little about it. Lucy jones says that if you adjust the magnitudes for whats possible along the real san andreas fault, the movie s triggering pattern is plausible. The effect of dark matter colliding with the earth is the opening of this film. San andreas the movie pretends that california has a subduction zone. May 28, 2015 the new dwayne johnson movie san andreas is a heartpumping thrill ride, a throwback to the peopleinperil disaster flicks that irwin allen made in the 1970s but with stateoftheart special. May 29, 2015 while youre typically supposed to refrain from texting during a movie, we find no fault in dr. The movie then moves on to nonsensical made up terms like lateralskip, took surface soil samples to prove the depth of the fault facepalm, and looks to fuse together the san andreas fault.
New san andreas trailer does a pretty great job of. Whats scientifically wrong with the san andreas movie. All the science san andreas gets wrong, according to a top. Here you will find unforgettable moments, scenes and lines from all. I think it is when ray must save his daughter from drowning. May 24, 2015 the san andreas system in northern california consists of five major branches with an overall length of about 1,25o miles. Mythbusting the new san andreas movie sorting fact from fiction posted on june 3, 2015 by devongeography i managed to catch the new movie san andreas last night perfect timing for a unit of work i had just started with year nine students, looking at earthquake preparedness in california. In san andreas, california is experiencing a statewide earthquake that goes on record as easily the biggest earthquake in history.
As an earth scientist and a science educator, i cringed when i saw, many months ago, a trailer for the new film san andreas. May 28, 2015 is san andreas scientifically accurate. The movie also seemed to suggest that an aftershock is more likely to occur if you are having a heartfelt conversation with. Dwyane johnson doesnt really obey the laws of physics, but helicopters do so when he dives on to try and restart the blades in. But in an interview this fall, goldfinger said the miniseries was possibly prescient about one thing. While youre typically supposed to refrain from texting during a movie, we find no fault in dr. Shaking from even the largest possible san andreas fault events will not be felt on the east coast, as described in the movie. The new movie san andreas, starring dwayne johnson better known as the. But i do expect them to hold true to their model of reality instead of changing their movie physics halfway through. Geological survey seismologist lucy jones has been reassuring californians much of what they see on the screen like the san andreas fault splitting open, or hoover. New earthquake research to be presented by oregonbased geologists next week sounds like a b movie. Jul 20, 2015 released in late spring 2015, the movie san andreas tells the story of massive earthquakes devastating california as a helicopter pilot and his formerly estranged wife try to find and rescue.
How realistic is the earthquake and tsunami depicted in. The san andreas fault is the drifting boundary between the pacific plate and the north american plate. San andreas, hollywoods latest natural disaster blockbuster, played on. The batman begins, which is a fan film which reenacts christopher nolans batman begins, but with a twist its in gta san andreas. The movie opens tomorrow, and judging by the prerelease media, the movie is replete with scientific errors. The best historical movies that are also mostly accurate. Seismologist highlights inaccuracies in upcoming san. Lucy jones says that if you adjust the magnitudes for whats possible along the real san andreas fault, the movies triggering pattern is plausible. May 28, 2015 12 movies to watch after you see san andreas. Could california really be destroyed by a series of earthquakes. Jun 04, 2015 how scientifically accurate is san andreas. And just for fun, geologist lucy jones tweeted some of the factual accuracies and inaccuracies of the movie while watching the premier. New earthquake research to be presented by oregonbased geologists next week shows a major quake from the offshore cascadia fault zone could trigger californias famous san andreas fault. Check out the right column for all of the things that the movie gets very.
Dec 09, 2015 much like most horror movies made in the last decade, or the entire transformers series, san andreas is entertaining, but not really in the way the director probably intended. Here you will find unforgettable moments, scenes and lines from all your favorite films. Hollywoods favorite geologic bad guy is back in san andreas a fantastical look at one of the worlds real seismic threats. San andreas 2015 movie mistakes, goofs and bloopers. Its important to note that what makes an entertaining and dramatic disaster movie may not be reality. It might not be perfect, but theres some solid truth to it. In the film san andreas creates an earthquake that splits the earth into two, but geologist lucy jone made a statement that part was fictional san andreas. The vast majority of great cascadia quakes during that period have a correlation on the san andreas fault. New san andreas trailer does a pretty great job of effing sf right up. Earthquake blockbuster shakes up the box office, but cnns jeanne moos asks how san andreas measures on the accuracy scale. With all these scientific inaccuracies, you may be wondering whether you should see san andreas or stay home and watch a good documentary. So if san andreas eventually emerges as a feelgood disaster movie, it probably just reflects our aspirations for maintaining order in the inevitable chaos of a catastrophic quake. Experts say there is a 99 percent chance of a magnitude6.
San andreas is now one of my favorite disaster movies. Research shows cascadia quakes sometimes trigger san andreas. May 27, 2015 scientists say san andreas is not accurate. This movie has many special effects and knowing this, we realize that most of the earthquake scenes had to be computer generated as are most disaster movies. For starters, you cant run in a major quake carla gugino in a scene from the new disaster film san andreas, which earthquake experts say is farfetched.
The shifty science behind the movie 2012 softpedia. Scientists found nine to eleven instances over roughly the last 3,000 years where a cascadia earthquake seems to have triggered a san andreas quake. What is the turning point of the movie san andreas. Mar 11, 2015 you might look at the newest trailer for san andreas and see the standard goofball disaster film. Further explore the accuracy of the san andreas movie through the videos below. She praises alexandra daddarios character, saying competence is sexy. All the science san andreas gets wrong, according to a.
The marine geologist said a major quake from the offshore cascadia fault zone could trigger californias famous san andreas fault. Always wish someone would post the dvds bc i like to know if its 5 individual disc or like this the dvd case hold all 3 dvd are stacked on top of each other i hate this personally wish it would be in a 3 disc no behind the scenes or deleted scenes on the san andreas disc or into the storm did not look at the perfect storm disc. The websites critical consensus reads, san andreas has a great cast and outstanding special effects, but amidst all the sensesshattering destruction, the movie s characters and plot prove less than structurally sound. Research shows cascadia quakes sometimes trigger san. Jones, however, called out san andreas for several inaccuracies, such as these. While driving the stolen truck, the san andreas fault has cut off the road, with the opposite west side of the fault the pacific plate shifting left southward. Seismologist screens the rocks san andreas, outlines all of its gross inaccuracies the film got a surprising amount of things right, but a lot of the science hilariously wrong.
Dwayne johnson left and carla gugino star in san andreas, a movie about a massive earthquake that strikes california. Actually, even where plates are moving away from each other, deep open cracks like this do not form. I also expect to be absorbed in the movie and entertained. How realistic is the earthquake and tsunami depicted in san. I thought the scenes of the destruction were amazing. Actor dwayne johnson has said an expert seismologist signed off on the script for san andreas, but the us geological survey. And there were almost too many inaccuracies to count. Seismologist lucile jones discusses how accurate or not the plot of this new california earthquake thriller really is. Maine is geologically old, and while it does have a moderate level of widespread earthquake activity, it does not have active faults like. A seismologist explores the scientific accuracy of san andreas. May 29, 2015 as an earth scientist and a science educator, i cringed when i saw, many months ago, a trailer for the new film san andreas. But she also highlighted some grains of truth about. The san andreas fault is the faint line running left to right in this aerial photograph. Given the size and geometry of the faults, the odds of an earthquake above magnitude 8.
1356 912 1122 385 1481 263 976 1589 1235 831 422 846 833 1394 1547 382 773 1498 536 218 565 947 1585 1321 986 1 571 1250 506 2 815 600 787 623 28 644